New CMS guidance a “missed opportunity” for future medical innovation, patients

June 30, 2023 | Source BIO.org

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) today released its guidance for the Drug Price Negotiation Program (Negotiation Program) under the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 (IRA). John Murphy, BIO’s Chief Policy Officer, made the following statement: 

Biotechnology Innovation Organization (BIO) logo

“As we have stated in the past, the Medicare price setting provisions of the IRA will have a profound and lasting negative impact on innovative medicine development and access in the US.  Nothing in the final guidance released today will change that. Unfortunately, patients – and their loved ones – will be robbed of the future medical innovation that they’re so desperately waiting for as this law rolls out.  

“CMS took some limited steps in the final guidance that will modestly improve the environment around transparency. Although much more could have been done.  

“Notably, we were pleased to see CMS take the reasonable position of allowing affected manufacturers to control some of their own disclosures and confidentiality protections surrounding the negotiation process.  

“Similarly, CMS clarified the ability of interested parties and patients to have a voice in the negotiation process.  Moreover, Part D plans are now on notice that MFP-selected drugs are going to have to be accessible to patients once negotiated. Although, it remains unclear how much CMS will increase formulary review to ensure unreasonable utilization management is not implemented as a barrier to access.  

“Yet the Agency missed the opportunity to repair damage to the rare disease community and support more meaningful investment in orphan research by allowing new but unapproved orphan designations to retain the orphan exclusion.  We believe CMS has the authority and discretion to make this clarification and to support rare disease patients. 

“BIO and our members will continue to pursue all avenues available to protect patient access to medicines and to ensure the US remains an open market for innovation and investment.”

By Maria Thacker Goethe May 8, 2025
Disclaimer: This statement was published on May 9, 2025, at 12:11 PM and is subject to change as the administration moves forward with policy decisions. -- In a rapidly developing situation, the White House is poised to take executive action on prescription drug pricing that could significantly impact the biopharmaceutical industry. Early next week, the president is expected to sign an executive order directing administration officials to pursue a "Most Favored Nation" initiative, which would tie U.S. government drug payments to lower prices paid abroad, according to sources familiar with the matter who were granted anonymity to discuss internal deliberations. This executive order would bypass the legislative discussions previously reported in Congress, where Republicans on the House Energy and Commerce Committee had been considering similar measures as potential spending cuts. While the plan hasn't been finalized and could still change as officials work through specifics, the move signals the administration's intent to act quickly on drug pricing. If enacted, the MFN policy could be paired with other proposed changes, such as increasing the 23.1% Medicaid base rebate. Reports suggest that manufacturers might be required to pay either the MFN price or the higher rebate—whichever yields the lowest cost for the government. This policy would create severe financial pressure on drug developers, particularly small and mid-size companies that are essential to Georgia’s thriving life sciences ecosystem. Georgia is home to a growing network of biotech, pharmaceutical, and medical technology firms—many of which are advancing groundbreaking treatments for rare diseases, pediatric conditions, and underserved populations. These companies often operate with little commercial revenue and rely on a balanced, predictable pricing framework to continue investing in innovation. In 2023, pharmaceutical companies provided $54 billion in Medicaid rebates nationally, helping keep drug spending to just 5.9% of total Medicaid expenditures . The current system works by ensuring broad patient access to medicine while enabling companies to reinvest in research and development. Drastic changes such as MFN pricing would upend this balance and threaten job creation and investment in states like Georgia. Moreover, because Medicaid rebate amounts are tied to 340B discount calculations, the impact would extend far beyond Medicaid—further increasing costs in the already-burdened 340B program. In response, Georgia Life Sciences has joined a coalition of more than 40 state bioscience associations, signing onto a letter from the Council of State Bioscience Associations (CSBA) opposing any MFN or foreign reference pricing schemes. The letter highlights the harm such policies would inflict on rare disease patients, pediatric populations, and emerging biotechnology companies. “Rather than penalizing innovative companies that develop treatments for vulnerable patients, we should work together to ensure the U.S. maintains its strategic leadership in biopharmaceutical innovation and that American patients have access to the best treatments available.” — CSBA Letter, May 2025 Georgia Life Sciences is actively monitoring the situation and preparing to advocate on behalf of Georgia’s life sciences community.
By Sheran Brown May 1, 2025
Opinion: Georgia's Congressional delegation can lead the way on correcting 'pill penalty'  Maria Thacker Goethe President and CEO, Georgia Life Sciences: May 1, 2025 EPIC Act offers commonsense fix to 'pill penalty' problem
By Maria Thacker Goethe April 18, 2025
The Science & Community Impacts Mapping Project (SCIMaP) shows how proposed federal funding cuts lead to reduced economic activity and job losses nationwide.
MORE POSTS